Order for this Paper or Similar Assignment Writing Help

Fill a form in 3 easy steps - less than 5 mins.

Posted: August 21st, 2023

Austere Nominalism: A Minimalist Approach to Universals

Austere Nominalism: A Minimalist Approach to Universals

Austere nominalism is a metaphysical view that denies the existence of universals, abstract objects, and properties. According to austere nominalists, there are only concrete particulars that have primitive features or characters. These features are not shared by different particulars, nor do they exist independently of them. Austere nominalism is a radical form of nominalism that rejects any kind of realism about universals or properties.

One of the main motivations for austere nominalism is to avoid the ontological and epistemological problems that arise from postulating universals or properties. For example, if there are universals or properties, how do we account for their nature, identity, and individuation? How do we explain their causal efficacy and their relation to particulars? How do we access them and know about them? Austere nominalists claim that these problems are insoluble and that we should adopt a more parsimonious and naturalistic ontology that does not involve any abstract entities.

Another motivation for austere nominalism is to preserve the simplicity and clarity of language and logic. Austere nominalists argue that we do not need to posit universals or properties to make sense of our ordinary discourse and reasoning. They maintain that predicates, such as “red” or “round”, do not refer to anything other than the concrete particulars that they apply to. They also hold that sentences, such as “a is red” or “a is round”, do not express any relations between particulars and universals or properties, but only state facts about the features of particulars. Austere nominalists adopt a deflationary or minimalist account of truth, according to which sentences are true if and only if they correspond to the facts.

One of the main challenges for austere nominalism is to explain the phenomenon of resemblance or similarity among particulars. If there are no universals or properties, how can we account for the fact that some particulars are alike in some respects and different in others? How can we make sense of generalizations, classifications, and comparisons based on resemblance? Austere nominalists have two main strategies to deal with this challenge. One strategy is to deny that resemblance is a real feature of the world and to treat it as a subjective or pragmatic matter. According to this view, resemblance is not something that requires explanation, but only a way of grouping or ordering particulars according to our interests and purposes. Another strategy is to accept that resemblance is a real feature of the world, but to explain it in terms of primitive characters or features of particulars. According to this view, resemblance is a basic and unanalyzable fact that does not involve any relations between particulars and universals or properties.

Austere nominalism is a controversial and radical view that has been defended by some prominent philosophers, such as Nelson Goodman, W.V.O. Quine, David Lewis, and Gonzalo Rodriguez-Pereyra. It has also been criticized by many others, who have argued that it fails to account for the richness and complexity of reality, language, and thought. Some of the objections raised against austere nominalism are:

– It cannot explain the apparent generality and objectivity of our knowledge and discourse.
– It cannot account for the possibility of error and disagreement about resemblance.
– It cannot accommodate the role of mathematics and logic in science and philosophy.
– It cannot provide a satisfactory analysis of modality, causation, and counterfactuals.
– It cannot avoid committing itself to some form of realism about primitive features or characters.

Austere nominalism is a challenging and intriguing view that raises fundamental questions about the nature of reality and our understanding of it. It invites us to reconsider our assumptions and intuitions about what exists and what we can know.

References:

Carroll, J.W., & Markosian, N. (2010). An introduction to metaphysics. Cambridge University Press.

Loux, M.J. (2006). Metaphysics: A contemporary introduction (3rd ed.). Routledge.

Rodriguez-Pereyra, G. (2002). Resemblance nominalism: A solution to the problem of universals. Oxford University Press.

Tags:

Why choose us

You Want Quality and That’s What We Deliver

Top Skilled Writers

Our writing team is assembled through a rigorous selection process, where we handpick accomplished writers with specialized expertise in distinct subject areas and a proven track record in academic writing. Each writer brings a unique blend of knowledge and skills to the table, ensuring that our content is not only informative but also engaging and accessible to a general college student audience

Discounted Prices

Competitive pricing is a cornerstone of our service, where we balance affordability with exceptional quality. In offering the best writers at rates that rival other writing services, we ensure that students can access top-notch content without breaking the bank unnecessarily. Our fair and transparent pricing structure is designed to provide value for money, making us a go-to choice for students seeking high-quality writing services at an affordable price.

100% Plagiarism-Free

Academic integrity is paramount to our writing service, which is why we produce original research and writing content for every paper. Each piece of work is carefully written from scratch, ensuring that every sentence, paragraph, and page is authentic and free from plagiarism. Our rigorous quality control process involves thorough scanning of every final draft, guaranteeing that the content meets the highest standards of originality and academic integrity. With keen attention to citation and referencing, we ensure that every source is properly credited, giving you complete peace of mind. We also have the best plagiarism checkers like safeassign and turnitin thus providing similarity score for each paper.

How it works

When you decide to place an order with Homework Ace Tutors, here is what happens:

Complete the Order Form

You will complete our order form, filling in all of the fields and giving us as much detail as possible.

Assignment of Writer

We analyze your order and match it with a writer who has the unique qualifications to complete it, and he begins from scratch.

Order in Production and Delivered

You and your writer communicate directly during the process, and, once you receive the final draft, you either approve it or ask for revisions.

Giving us Feedback (and other options)

We want to know how your experience went. You can read other clients’ testimonials too. And among many options, you can choose a favorite writer.