Order For This Paper, Written Essays or Similar Assignment Help Services.

Fill the details/instructions form and checkout for your essay - pro writers; top college graduates only in less than 5 mins, NO AI—Plagiarism-free!.

Posted: October 31st, 2023

Edmund Gettier’s Two Counterexamples to the Justified True Belief Theory of Knowledge

Briefly explain Edmund Gettier’s two counterexamples to the justified-true-belief theory of knowledge. Don’t overthink the assignment. Just do the best you can in explaining Gettier’s two counterexamples and submit the assignment by the due date. For help in completing the assignment, read pp. 143-45 of the Norton.

Word Count: 300-500.

Edmund Gettier’s Two Counterexamples to the Justified True Belief Theory of Knowledge
Edmund Gettier famously presented two counterexamples in 1963 that challenged the long-held “justified true belief” theory of knowledge. Under the justified true belief view, in order to have knowledge of a proposition, one must have a justified true belief in that proposition. Gettier argued that justified true belief is not sufficient for knowledge. His two cases demonstrated that it is possible to have a justified true belief in a proposition that is indeed true, yet not have knowledge.
In Gettier’s first case, Smith has strong evidence that leads him to form the justified true belief that “Jones will get the job, and Jones has ten coins in his pocket” (Gettier, 1963, p. 121). However, unbeknownst to Smith, it is actually Smith himself who will get the job, not Jones. And coincidentally, Smith also happens to have ten coins in his pocket. So while Smith’s belief that “Jones will get the job, and Jones has ten coins in his pocket” ends up being true, it is true by luck rather than knowledge, since Smith was wrong about Jones getting the job.
In Gettier’s second case, Brown has strong evidence that leads him to form the justified true belief that “Jones owns a Ford” (Gettier, 1963, p. 121). However, unknown to Brown, Jones had sold his Ford and bought a Chevrolet instead. But coincidentally, Jones’s friend Smith owns a Ford. So while Brown’s belief that “Jones owns a Ford” ends up being true, it is true by luck rather than knowledge, since Brown was wrong about which car Jones owns.
These two cases demonstrated that justified true belief is not sufficient for knowledge, since one can have a justified true belief that is true due merely to luck or coincidence, rather than knowledge. Gettier’s counterexamples have been highly influential in epistemology and the philosophy of knowledge. Numerous attempts have since been made to modify the justified true belief definition of knowledge to account for Gettier-style cases.
References:
Gettier, E. L. (1963). Is justified true belief knowledge?. Analysis, 23(6), 121-123. https://doi.org/10.1093/analys/23.6.121
Zalta, E. N. (Ed.). (2020). Edmund Gettier. In The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Fall 2020 Edition). Metaphysics Research Lab, Stanford University. https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/fall2020/entries/gettier/
Zagzebski, L. (1994). The Inescapability of Gettier Problems. The Philosophical Quarterly, 44(174), 65-73. http://www.jstor.org/stable/2220112

Order | Check Discount

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Find The Best Writers, Tutors & Assignment Experts!

2025 Special Offer! Get 20-25% Off On ALL Your Orders!

Why trust us?

Every student wants the best grades and that’s our Focus

Graduate Level Writers

Our team consists of outstanding writers who have specialized knowledge in specific subject areas and professionals experienced in academic research writing. They hold at least a graduate degree—230 with Masters and MSN qualifications, experts carefully selected and trained to ensure the best quality of our work. .

College Students Prices

We’re dedicated to bringing on board top-notch writers who can provide excellent work at prices that make sense for college students; affordable papers. Our goal? To give you the best bang for your buck without ever compromising on the quality of our essay writing services—or the content of your paper. #Don’t forget to use the DISCOUNT code in the COUPONS section of the order form before you pay!.

100% Human Written

The service guarantees that our final work is 100% original, rearched and human written expertly. We are committed to delivering plagiarism-free and AI-free work to each university/college student's 'write my paper' request. To uphold this promise, we check every draft for any possible instances of duplication, wrong citation, grammar errors and artificiality before we send it to you. Thus, you can always rely on us to write genuine and high-standard content for your essay assignments.

How it works

When you trust to place an order with Homework Ace Tutors, here is what happens:

Complete the Order Form

Please fill out our order form completely, providing as much detail as possible in all the required fields.

Assignment of Writer

We carefully review your order and assign it to a skilled writer with the specific expertise needed to handle it. The writer then creates your content entirely from scratch.

Order in Progress and Submission

You, along with the support team and your assigned writer, communicate directly throughout the process. Once the final draft is delivered, you can either approve it or request edits, paraphrasing, or a complete revision.

Giving us Feedback(review our essay service)

Ultimately, we value your feedback on how your experience went. You can also explore testimonials from other clients. Additionally, you have the option to recommend or select your preferred writer for any future orders.

Write My Essay For Me